Nonprofit fundraising has never been easy. But today, the pressure is coming from every direction.
Demand for services is rising. Government funding is shifting. Foundation priorities are changing. Donors expect greater transparency. Boards want more predictable revenue. And development teams are being asked to accomplish more, often without more staff, stronger systems, or additional resources.
That creates a question every nonprofit board should be asking:
Is our leadership team truly built for this funding environment?
The answer is not simply whether your organization has a development department. It is whether your CEO, chief development officer, advancement leaders, and board are aligned around a shared revenue strategy.
That distinction matters because the fundraising leadership gap is rarely just an open position. It is often a gap in ownership, strategy, communication, or organizational readiness.
What the Latest Data Tells Us
The Center for Effective Philanthropy’s September 2026 research offers a revealing look at the pressure nonprofit leaders are facing.
CEP found that 60% of nonprofit CEOs would find help with fundraising strategy and donor development useful. Yet only 40% of foundations reported providing fundraising assistance as a form of support beyond the grant.
The research also found that:
- Only one-third of surveyed independent foundations reported a higher payout rate.
- Fifty-eight percent of nonprofit leaders said they were less than completely honest with funders about the challenges their organizations face.
- Among those leaders, 68% feared that greater honesty could jeopardize future funding.
- Ninety-three percent of foundation CEOs had made at least one change to their approach, confirming that funders are adjusting their strategies, too.
The message is clear: nonprofits are operating in a more demanding and less predictable funding environment, while many leaders feel they lack the support, resources, or freedom to respond openly.
This is not only a fundraising challenge. It is a leadership challenge.
What Strong Nonprofit Fundraising Leadership Looks Like Today
When revenue falls short, the first instinct is often to blame the development team or begin searching for a new chief development officer.
Sometimes a leadership change is necessary. But a new hire cannot succeed in a system that is not prepared to support fundraising.
Before launching a search, boards should look beyond the job title and ask:
- Who owns the organization’s revenue strategy?
- Is the CEO actively engaged with donors and funders?
- Does the board understand its role in relationship-building and philanthropy?
- Are fundraising goals based on real data and sufficient capacity?
- Does the development team have the authority, systems, and resources needed to deliver?
- Are the CEO and CDO aligned on priorities, messaging, and accountability?
If those answers are unclear, the organization may have a fundraising leadership gap even when every position is filled.
What Boards Should Expect From Today’s Nonprofit CEO
Not every nonprofit CEO needs to be a career fundraiser. Every CEO, however, must understand that revenue leadership is part of the job.
The strongest CEOs do not delegate all responsibility for fundraising to the development department. They create the conditions in which fundraising can succeed.
-
Ownership of the Revenue Strategy
The CEO should understand where revenue comes from, where concentration creates risk, and which funding streams offer the greatest opportunity.
That means being able to discuss more than the annual fundraising goal. The CEO should understand donor retention, major-gift pipelines, grant renewal risk, corporate partnerships, unrestricted revenue, and the cost of raising funds.
-
Credible Communication With Funders
CEP’s finding that many nonprofit leaders hold back with funders deserves board attention.
Effective CEOs must be able to communicate challenges honestly without creating unnecessary alarm. They need to explain what has changed, what the organization is doing about it, and how additional investment will produce results.
That requires judgment, transparency, and trust.
-
A Willingness to Be Visible
Fundraising is relational. Donors often want access to the person setting the vision and making the decisions.
A CEO who avoids donor meetings, hesitates to make an ask, or treats fundraising as someone else’s responsibility places an artificial ceiling on the organization’s potential.
-
The Ability to Connect Mission and Money
Strong nonprofit CEOs can explain how funding decisions affect programs, people, outcomes, and long-term sustainability. They make the financial case for the mission without reducing the mission to numbers.
That ability becomes especially important when donors are cautious and funders are changing priorities.
What Boards Should Seek When They Hire a Chief Development Officer
If your nonprofit is preparing to hire a chief development officer, vice president of advancement, or senior fundraising executive, it is tempting to focus on one qualification: how much money the candidate has raised.
That number matters, but it does not tell the whole story.
A candidate’s past results were shaped by the organization’s brand, donor base, board engagement, staff support, systems, and market conditions. Boards need to understand how the candidate achieved those results and whether the same capabilities will translate to a new environment.
Look for a leader who can:
Build a Diversified Revenue Strategy
Today’s CDO must be able to look across individual giving, major gifts, foundations, corporations, planned giving, events, digital fundraising, and other revenue channels. The goal is not to pursue everything. It is to build the right mix for the organization.
Turn Data Into Decisions
Fundraising leaders should understand pipeline health, donor retention, portfolio performance, conversion rates, forecasting, and return on investment. More importantly, they should be able to translate that data into clear choices for the CEO and board.
Strengthen Donor and Funder Trust
The best advancement leaders are not simply strong solicitors. They listen well, communicate clearly, and build confidence over time. They know how to discuss setbacks, changing priorities, and urgent needs without weakening the relationship.
Build Teams and Systems
A sustainable fundraising program cannot depend entirely on one person’s relationships. Strong CDOs develop staff, establish processes, improve technology, document institutional knowledge, and create accountability.
Lead Across the Organization
Fundraising touches programs, finance, marketing, communications, executive leadership, and the board. A CDO must be able to influence across those functions, even when they do not directly manage them.
The CEO and CDO Partnership Is the Real Competitive Advantage
Organizations often talk about hiring an exceptional fundraiser. What they need just as much is an exceptional CEO and CDO partnership.
When that partnership works, the CEO and CDO present a unified vision to donors. They agree on priorities. They share information. They clarify who owns each relationship. They bring the board into the process with purpose.
When it does not work, fundraising becomes reactive. Donors receive mixed messages. Goals are disconnected from capacity. The CDO is held responsible for outcomes without receiving the access, authority, or support required to achieve them.
Boards should look for evidence that CEO and CDO candidates can operate as strategic partners. During the search process, ask candidates to describe:
- How they have shared responsibility for fundraising with another senior leader
- How they handled disagreement over revenue goals or donor strategy
- How they engaged reluctant board members in fundraising
- How they communicated financial pressure to major funders
- How they balanced immediate revenue needs with long-term relationship-building
These questions reveal far more than asking candidates to recite their largest gifts.
What Advancement Leaders Need to Deliver Now
The fundraising leadership gap is not limited to the C-suite.
Vice presidents, development directors, major-gift officers, corporate partnership leaders, and foundation-relations professionals are also operating in a more complex environment.
Boards and executives should prioritize advancement leaders who can:
- Build meaningful donor relationships rather than rely on transactional outreach
- Use data and technology without losing the human side of fundraising
- Collaborate with program and finance teams
- Communicate impact clearly and credibly
- Adapt when funding priorities or donor behavior change
- Build a healthy pipeline instead of chasing only immediate gifts
These capabilities are especially important when the strongest fundraising professionals may not be actively applying for jobs. A job posting can attract applicants. Recruiting proven, mission-aligned leaders often requires direct outreach, careful assessment, and a compelling case for why the opportunity is worth considering.
Five Signs Your Nonprofit Is Not Built for Today’s Funding Environment
Your organization may have a fundraising leadership gap if:
- Fundraising belongs entirely to the development team. The CEO and board participate only when asked.
- Revenue goals are set without examining staff capacity, donor pipelines, or market conditions.
- One grant, event, donor, or government contract represents an outsized share of revenue.
- Development leadership changes frequently, but the organization’s expectations and support remain the same.
- The CEO and CDO tell different stories about priorities, performance, or what the organization needs next.
If several of these signs sound familiar, hiring alone will not solve the problem. The board must first clarify the leadership model, expectations, resources, and measures of success.
Before You Begin a Fundraising Leadership Search
Before starting a search, boards should answer six questions:
- What must this leader accomplish during the first 12 to 24 months?
- Which revenue streams require immediate attention?
- What role will the CEO play in fundraising?
- What will the board be expected to contribute?
- Does the position have the authority, staff, technology, and budget needed to succeed?
- How will success be measured beyond total dollars raised?
The answers should shape the position profile, candidate outreach, interview questions, and assessment process.
Without that clarity, organizations risk hiring an accomplished leader into an unworkable role.
The Bottom Line
The current funding environment is not simply asking nonprofits to raise more money. It is asking them to lead differently.
Boards need CEOs who treat revenue as a strategic responsibility. They need CDOs who can diversify income, build systems, and strengthen trust. They need advancement leaders who combine data, relationships, adaptability, and mission alignment.
Most importantly, they need a leadership team that operates together.
If your nonprofit is preparing to hire a chief development officer, CEO, or advancement leader, do not begin with the job description. Begin with the organization’s funding strategy, leadership expectations, and future direction.
The right search is not just about filling the fundraising leadership gap. It is about building the leadership capacity your mission will require next.
The Batten Group partners with nonprofit, healthcare, higher education, and mission-driven organizations to recruit exceptional executives and fundraising leaders. With more than 700 successful searches nationwide, we help organizations define what they need, engage proven passive candidates, and identify leaders equipped to advance both mission and sustainable growth.
Ready to strengthen your fundraising leadership? Schedule a complimentary leadership consultation with The Batten Group.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is nonprofit fundraising leadership?
Nonprofit fundraising leadership is the ability to create and execute a sustainable revenue strategy, build donor and funder relationships, align internal teams, engage the board, and connect financial goals to the organization’s mission.
When should a nonprofit hire a chief development officer?
A nonprofit should consider hiring a chief development officer when revenue strategy has become too complex for the CEO or development director to manage alone, when the organization is preparing for significant growth, or when it needs senior leadership across multiple fundraising channels.
What should a board look for in a chief development officer?
Boards should evaluate strategic thinking, revenue diversification, donor relationship management, team leadership, data fluency, cross-functional influence, and the candidate’s ability to partner effectively with the CEO and board.
What is the ideal CEO and CDO partnership?
An effective CEO and CDO partnership includes shared revenue goals, clear roles, regular communication, coordinated donor engagement, consistent messaging, and mutual accountability for fundraising success.
Can hiring a new CDO solve a nonprofit’s fundraising problems?
Not by itself. A new CDO can provide strategy and leadership, but sustainable success also requires realistic expectations, CEO participation, board engagement, adequate resources, reliable systems, and organizational alignment.
About The Batten Group
At The Batten Group, we believe the right leader can transform an entire organization.
We are a national nonprofit executive search firm with more than 75 years of combined experience placing CEOs, development officers, and senior leaders across nonprofit, healthcare, higher education, and mission-based organizations.
Our work goes beyond résumés. We identify transformational leaders who fit your culture, inspire your teams, and deliver long-term impact.
Learn more at thebattengroup.com, follow us on LinkedIn and X, or subscribe to our newsletter for leadership insights and nonprofit career opportunities.
