Your Executive Director just resigned.

Or your COO accepted another position.

Maybe your Chief Development Officer gave notice.

Whatever the scenario, you’re now facing a nonprofit executive transition—and if you’re like most nonprofit boards, you’re probably thinking about two things:

1. How much will this search cost?
2. How fast can we fill this seat?

Here’s the problem: those are the wrong questions.

Well, not wrong exactly. But incomplete.

Because the real cost of a nonprofit executive transition? It’s not the search fee. It’s not even the interim coverage.

It’s what’s happening to your organization every single day that position sits empty.

Let me show you what we mean.

You know these are coming. Your board treasurer already mentioned them.

Search firms? They typically charge 30% of the position’s annual salary. Some go higher.

So if you’re hiring an Executive Director at $150K, you’re looking at $45,000-$50,000 just for the search.

That stings. But it’s predictable.

Interim leadership is expensive.

You’ve got three options here, and they all cost money:

• Promote someone internally (now you’re backfilling their role)
• Hire an interim consultant (usually $150-$300/hour or more)
• Spread responsibilities across existing staff (hello, overtime and burnout)

Onboarding takes at least 3-6+ months.

Even exceptional leaders need 3-6+ months to build relationships, understand the history, and develop the organizational context that drives smart strategic decisions.

They’re learning your systems, building relationships, understanding your culture, and figuring out how things really get done.

During that time? Strategic work moves slower.

Add it all up, and you’re probably looking at $75,000-$150,000 in direct costs for a senior leadership transition.

That’s before we get to the stuff that really hurts.

After 650+ nonprofit leadership placements over 16 years, we can tell you exactly what happens during extended leadership vacancies.

And it’s not pretty.

Cost #1: Your Strategic Initiatives Die a Slow Death

Here’s what no one tells you:

Without permanent leadership, big decisions don’t get made. They get delayed.

That capital campaign you were planning? On hold.

The program expansion that would serve 500 more families? Pushed to next year.

The strategic partnership with that health system? They’re waiting to see “who the new leader is.”

Real example: A healthcare nonprofit we worked with had a six-month COO vacancy.

Six months doesn’t sound that long, right?

Except that delay pushed their program expansion back an entire year.

Cost? $2 million in unrealized revenue. Plus thousands of community members who went unserved.

That’s not a search cost. That’s a mission cost.

Cost #2: Your Donors Start Getting Nervous

Let us ask you something:

Would you write a six-figure check to an organization that’s been without an Executive Director for eight months?

Your major donors are asking themselves the same question.

So are your foundation partners.

Here’s what we see happen:

• Major gift conversations get put “on pause”
• Foundation grants get delayed or reduced
• Corporate sponsors want to “wait and see how things shake out”
• Individual donors start quietly redirecting their giving

No one says it out loud. But everyone’s thinking it:

Is this organization stable? Should I be concerned?

Every month that vacancy stretches on, you’re losing donor confidence.

And rebuilding it? That takes years, not months.

Cost #3: Your Best People Start Looking Around

Your staff isn’t just waiting for you to hire someone.

They’re working their butts off, picking up extra responsibilities, and wondering when things will get back to normal.

Here’s the harsh truth:

Your high performers will leave first.

They’re the ones with options. They’re the ones getting LinkedIn messages from recruiters. They’re the ones who can afford to be picky.

And when they start leaving? You’ve got a new problem.

Because replacing mid-level talent costs 50-75% of their annual salary. Each.

One executive departure can trigger a cascade of turnover that costs you more than the original vacancy.

We watched one organization lose its ED, then three program directors within six months.

Total cost to replace everyone? North of $200,000.

Plus, the institutional knowledge that walked out the door? Priceless.

Cost #4: Your Mission Takes a Hit

This is the one that keeps us up at night.

While you’re searching for the right leader, who’s ensuring your programs maintain quality?

Who’s advocating for policy changes that affect your community?

Who’s positioning your organization as THE leader in your space?

The mission doesn’t pause during a leadership search.

But mission advancement often does.

Here’s a stat that should scare you:

Leadership vacancies that extend beyond 90 days exponentially increase organizational risk.

Everything we just described? It accelerates after day 90.

But here’s the catch:

Rushing to fill the seat in 60 days with the wrong person? That costs even more.

Bad executive hires cost 3-5x their annual salary when you factor in:

• Severance packages
• Restart the search
• Organizational disruption
• More staff turnover
• Damaged stakeholder relationships

So you need speed AND quality.

How do you get both?

After working with hundreds of nonprofit boards, we can tell you exactly what separates organizations that nail executive transitions from those that struggle.

They Don’t Wait for a Crisis

The best boards are thinking about succession planning when everyone’s still employed and happy.

They’re asking:

• What leadership competencies will we need in 2-3 years?
• What’s our internal pipeline look like?
• Who are the rising stars in our sector that we should know?

Succession planning isn’t about emergencies. It’s about readiness.

They Know What They Actually Need

Most job descriptions are useless.

They’re a laundry list of responsibilities and qualifications that could apply to a hundred different organizations.

High-performing boards get specific:

What problem are you solving by filling this role?

What leadership gap exists right now?

What does success look like in year one? Year three?

What kind of change agent does your organization need at THIS moment?

The more clarity you have, the faster you’ll recognize the right candidate.

They Partner with People Who Know the Sector

Look, we’re biased here. We’re a nonprofit-specialized search firm.

But here’s why that matters:

Generalist recruiters can find qualified candidates.

They’re great at matching resumes to job descriptions.

But nonprofit leadership? That’s different.

You need someone who understands:

• Mission alignment (it’s real, and it matters)
• Nonprofit compensation realities
• Board dynamics and governance
• How to assess cultural fit in mission-driven environments
• The specific challenges facing nonprofits right now

The right search partner saves you months of trial and error.

The wrong one costs you six months and $50,000 with nothing to show for it.

They Communicate Like Adults

Here’s a mistake we see constantly:

Boards that go radio silent during leadership transitions.

They think they’re “protecting the organization” or “maintaining professionalism.”

What they’re actually doing? Creating anxiety and speculation.

Your staff deserves to know your timeline and process.

Your donors deserve regular updates.

Your community partners deserve transparency.

Silence doesn’t project confidence. It projects fear.

Executive transitions are expensive.

But not because of search fees or interim coverage.

They’re expensive because of what happens to your organization—your mission, your team, your impact—while that seat sits empty.

The question isn’t whether you can afford expert help with your leadership transition.

The question is whether you can afford to go it alone.

After 16 years and 650+ placements, we can tell you:

The organizations that treat executive transitions as strategic opportunities—not just operational headaches—are the ones that come out stronger.

They invest in getting it right, not just getting it done.

So here’s our challenge to you:

If you’re facing a leadership transition right now, stop thinking about this as a hiring project.

Start thinking about it as a mission-critical moment that will define your organization’s next chapter.

Because that’s exactly what it is.

The Batten Group’s commitment to finding mission-driven leaders is not just a recruitment strategy—it’s a dedication to the long-term success of nonprofit organizations and their missions. The true art of executive search lies in identifying authentic passion, aligning it with the right expertise, and matching it to the unique purpose of each organization. By doing so, The Batten Group helps nonprofits thrive and drive meaningful, lasting change.

In the nonprofit world, values-driven leadership isn’t a luxury—it’s essential. And The Batten Group is at the forefront of making that essential leadership a reality.

We are a premier national executive search and consultancy firm with more than 75 years of collective experience in nonprofit, philanthropy, and executive recruitment. We specialize in placing transformational leaders in nonprofit, healthcare, higher education, and mission-based organizations across the country.

As experts in recruiting and talent acquisition, our mission is to connect exceptional individuals with purpose-driven organizations—helping our partners achieve their boldest strategic goals.

We believe the most impactful teams are built by welcoming varied perspectives, lived experiences, and leadership styles. That belief is at the core of every search we conduct. By fostering environments where people feel seen, supported, and empowered, we help build stronger, more resilient leadership for the future.

We’d love to learn more about your organization’s goals and how we can support your search for the next transformational leader. Visit thebattengroup.com to learn more, or click here to explore our proven hiring methodology.

Follow us on LinkedIn and X to stay updated on our latest searches. And don’t forget to sign up for our monthly newsletter for expert tips, leadership insights, and new career opportunities across the nonprofit sector. [Click here to subscribe].